I’ll say it plainly: this is the kind of pitching idea that sounds smarter the second time you hear it, which is usually how baseball talks itself into trouble. Zac Gallen may be cheaper now, but cheaper is not the same thing as better, and the Cubs should know the difference by now.

The whole thing has a little history to it, and not the flattering kind. A year ago, there was the messy episode where a report said Gallen had signed with the Cubs before the Winter Meetings. That deal never existed, because Gallen was actually getting married when the report surfaced. The supposed agreement would have paid him an average of $22 million per year over several seasons. Instead, he ended up on a one-year deal at that same salary, with his poor 2025 season and the qualifying offer attached to him clearly weighing on the market.

Now the twist is that the qualifying-offer burden is gone. That matters. It changes the math. It also does not magically change the pitcher.

According to Sahadev Sharma of The Athletic, the Cubs might be inclined to revisit talks with the 31-year-old starter this offseason. Sharma stopped short of saying both sides are actively interested, but he did note that the organization monitored Gallen’s market until he re-signed with the Diamondbacks just before the start of spring training. That is enough to suggest the Cubs have at least kept a file open, which is baseball’s version of saying, “We’re not done being curious.”

My take is that curiosity is fine, but priority is another matter entirely. Gallen’s 2026 season was worse than the one before it, and the numbers are not exactly whispering optimism. He posted a 6.07 ERA, a 5.34 FIP, and -0.1 fWAR. The deeper metrics were ugly too, with bottom-10 percentile finishes in whiff rate, strikeout rate, barrel rate, and hard-hit rate. That is not the profile of a rotation savior. That is the profile of a pitcher who needs a very specific argument made on his behalf.

And then there’s the health piece, which may be the most important part of all. After years of making at least 28 starts and averaging 183.5 innings between 2022 and 2023, his health finally betrayed him in 2026. That’s not a small footnote. That’s the part that turns a bounce-back bet into a gamble with a receipt.

So yes, the Cubs may finally get a shot at Zac Gallen without paying the price they feared. But if they do, they should treat it like depth, not destiny. In baseball, “cheaper” is often just another word for “less convincing.”

— Bill Farr